The Death of Pope Francis: What Comes Next for the Vatican and the Future of the Catholic Church

The Death of Pope Francis: What Comes Next for the Vatican and the Future of the Catholic Church

By Kevin J.S. Duska Jr.
Pre-Positioned Series The VaticanCatholicismGeopolitics

1. Pope Francis Is Dead—What That Means in Real Terms?

Pope Francis has died today in Rome at the age of 88. The Vatican confirmed his passing in an official statement delivered by Cardinal Pietro Parolin, the Vatican Secretary of State, signaling an institutional effort to project continuity and stability.

In his carefully worded address, Parolin emphasized the Pope’s legacy of mercy, reform, and commitment to the marginalized while reassuring the global Catholic community that the Church remains united in faith and governance. This is the first and most important indication that the transition of power is being tightly managed by the Vatican’s diplomatic and bureaucratic machinery.

While the world mourns, the Vatican’s internal structure is already in motion. The Papal Chamberlain has assumed temporary control, the College of Cardinals has been summoned, and preparations for the papal conclave are underway. Beneath the solemnity of mourning, a power struggle is unfolding.

Francis leaves behind a fractured Church, deeply divided between progressives who saw him as a necessary reformer and traditionalists who believed he was a dangerous departure from doctrine. His death marks not just the passing of a pope, but the beginning of a fight for the future of Catholicism.

The Vatican’s Announcement: A Calculated Statement

The timing, tone, and content of the Vatican’s announcement are revealing. Every word is carefully crafted to convey order, suppress speculation, and control the global narrative.

1. Timing of the Announcement: No Delays, No Surprises

  • The Vatican swiftly confirmed Francis’ death, ensuring no information vacuum that could fuel speculation or destabilization.
  • The lack of delay indicates that the transition was prepared well in advance, suggesting that his death was expected and institutionally managed.

2. Cardinal Pietro Parolin as the Face of the Transition

  • As Secretary of State, Parolin is the Vatican’s chief diplomat and the second most powerful figure in the Church.
  • His prominence in the announcement signals that the Vatican’s diplomatic arm is in control of the transition and is focused on preserving institutional continuity.
  • The fact that Parolin—not the Camerlengo—delivered the news suggests a deliberate effort to reassure world governments and maintain Vatican stability.

3. The Cause of Death: A Narrative of Peace and Expectation

  • The official statement attributes the Pope’s death to complications from pneumonia, compounded by a bronchial spasm and aspiration event.
  • Phrasing like “died peacefully” and “in the care of his doctors” is standard Vatican messaging, designed to project calm and suppress speculation.
  • Any lack of reference to prior health struggles could indicate an attempt to avoid scrutiny over how his final days were handled.

The choice to have Parolin deliver the statement—and to do so in a calm, bureaucratic tone—signals a Vatican that does not want to project crisis. But a smooth public transition does not mean there is no power struggle behind the scenes.

The Immediate Aftermath: Power Moves in the First 24 Hours

The moment a pope dies, Vatican operations shift into a pre-planned transition phase. The institutional choreography is designed to project continuity while key players move into position.

1. The Camerlengo Takes Formal Control

  • The Camerlengo (currently Cardinal Kevin Farrell) assumes temporary authority over Vatican affairs.
  • His immediate duties include:
    • Verifying the Pope’s death.
    • Sealing the papal apartments and preventing unauthorized access to Francis’ personal records.
    • Overseeing the destruction of the Fisherman’s Ring, which marks the official end of Francis’ papacy.

2. The Vatican Bank Freezes Assets

  • As per tradition, the Vatican Bank (IOR) has frozen all papal-related financial transactions.
  • This move is designed to prevent unauthorized transfers during the transition period.
  • Unusual financial activity in the coming days could indicate power struggles over Church finances.

3. The Funeral and Conclave Timeline is Set

  • Francis’ body has been transported to St. Peter’s Basilica, where he will lie in state for public mourning.
  • The College of Cardinals has been formally summoned to Rome, marking the official start of the interregnum—the period between popes.
  • The conclave to elect the next pope must be held within 15-20 days, setting the stage for a decisive ideological battle over the Church’s future.
[@portabletext/react] Unknown block type "image", specify a component for it in the `components.types` prop

What to Watch for in the Next 24 Hours

Although the Vatican will project an image of unity, the first day of the post-Francis era is a critical window into the real power struggle beneath the surface.

  • Does Parolin continue leading Vatican communications?
    • If Parolin maintains control of the message, the Church’s diplomatic wing remains dominant.
    • If conservative figures begin making public statements, it could indicate a push to shift the Church’s direction quickly.
  • Who is present at key internal meetings?
    • If Francis’ closest allies are sidelined, it suggests an immediate attempt to reverse his reforms.
    • If progressive figures like Cardinal Tagle or Cardinal Hollerich remain prominent, it may signal that Francis’ influence could extend into the next conclave.
  • Are there signs of financial or administrative shifts?
    • Does the Vatican Bank make any unusual moves?
    • Are any senior officials unexpectedly replaced?
    • Are conservative or reformist factions signaling their next moves?

While the public focuses on mourning, the real maneuvering is already underway.

The Geopolitical Stakes: The Vatican Beyond Religion

Francis was not just a religious leader—he was a major political figure. His death immediately shifts the Vatican’s global relationships.

  • The Vatican’s ties with China, the U.S., and Russia will shift.
    • Francis sought dialogue with Beijing, but conservatives may push a harder stance.
    • His neutrality on Ukraine angered some in the West; his successor may take a different approach.
  • The power struggle over Vatican doctrine will intensify.
    • Francis’ moves on climate policy, LGBTQ+ rights, and economic justice were controversial.
    • Conservatives now have an opening to reverse his changes.

With Parolin at the forefront, the Vatican wants the world to believe that stability is assured. But Francis’ death marks the beginning of a decisive battle over the Church’s future.

Conclusion: A Managed Transition, But an Uncertain Future

By having Cardinal Parolin deliver the news, the Vatican has signaled its desire for continuity, control, and order. But the reality is far more complex.

  • Francis’ death does not just end a papacy—it opens the door for a massive shift in Vatican power.
  • His opponents now have a chance to reshape the Church.
  • His allies will attempt to secure his legacy.
  • The College of Cardinals is now the most important battleground in the Catholic world.

Although the world watches the funeral and religious ceremonies, the real battle will be fought inside the conclave.

Whoever emerges as the next pope will not just inherit Francis’ legacy—they will decide whether to uphold or dismantle it.

For the Vatican, this is not just a transition. This is a defining moment.

2. What Killed Him? Medical vs. Political Realities

Pope Francis has died at the age of 88 following complications from pneumonia and a bronchial spasm that led to aspiration. The Vatican has framed his passing as peaceful and expected, emphasizing his declining health over the past several weeks.

While pneumonia in an elderly patient is a well-known risk factor for mortality, the sequence of events leading to his death, the Vatican’s management of information, and the underlying power dynamics at play suggest a more complex reality.

Francis was working up until his final days, approving canonizations, signing decrees, and making significant Vatican appointments despite clear signs of physical deterioration. The question is why.

  • Was he genuinely strong enough to perform these tasks, or was he pushed to continue working despite declining health?
  • Did the Vatican downplay the severity of his condition to project stability?
  • Did his medical care reflect best practices—or institutional priorities?
  • Was his death accelerated by political convenience, whether by medical inertia or a lack of aggressive intervention?

This section examines what we know, what we don’t know, and what the Vatican isn’t saying.

The Official Cause of Death: A Rapid Decline or Something More?

The official Vatican statement attributes the Pope’s death to respiratory complications resulting from pneumonia, compounded by a bronchial spasm and aspiration event. He had been hospitalized since February 14, 2025, and while reports initially suggested he was improving, his condition took a sudden turn for the worse.

In his final days:

  • February 25, 2025: From his hospital bed at Gemelli Hospital, Pope Francis approved several decrees, advancing the canonizations of José Gregorio Hernández and Bartolo Longo, along with the beatification of Father Emil Kapaun and Salvo D'Acquisto.
  • February 26, 2025: He appointed Sister Raffaella Petrini as President of the Pontifical Commission for Vatican City State—the first woman to hold the position.
  • February 27, 2025: The Vatican insisted he was “stable,” though he remained on high-flow oxygen therapy.
  • February 28, 2025: He suffered a bronchial spasm, aspirated vomit, and required non-invasive mechanical ventilation. His death followed shortly after.

While the official timeline suggests a straightforward medical decline, several red flags suggest a more complex interplay between his health and Vatican politics.

Was His Death a Matter of Medical Mismanagement—or Political Convenience?

1. The Vatican’s History of Concealing a Pope’s Decline

  • The Vatican has a long history of managing papal deaths to control public perception and avoid power struggles.
  • John Paul II’s condition was repeatedly downplayed until he was visibly incapacitated.
  • Benedict XVI’s resignation was carefully choreographed, and even today, there is speculation about the internal pressures leading to his departure.
  • With Francis, the Vatican publicly maintained the illusion of stability until the very end—despite clear evidence of severe illness.

2. The Role of Kidney Failure: A Silent Factor in His Death?

  • Reports from earlier in his hospitalization suggested signs of kidney insufficiency—a major red flag.
  • Kidney failure in pneumonia patients drastically increases mortality risk, and yet, it was never directly addressed in Vatican statements.
  • If his kidneys were failing behind the scenes, was this acknowledged and treated—or ignored as inevitable?

3. Was Aggressive Medical Treatment Considered or Withheld?

  • Given his status and access to the best medical care, why did his condition deteriorate so rapidly?
  • Did doctors opt for a more conservative approach due to his age, or were there internal pressures to let nature take its course?
  • If he had received dialysis or earlier ventilation, could he have survived longer?

The Final Days: Who Had Access & What Decisions Were Made?

1. Who Controlled Access to Pope Francis in His Last Hours?

  • The inner circle around a dying pope is a crucial indicator of power.
  • If only Vatican diplomats and the Curia were allowed near him, it suggests a tightly controlled transition.
  • If his closest personal aides were sidelined, it could mean the Vatican was preparing for a post-Francis shift before his death was even announced.

2. Were Last-Minute Vatican Decisions Made in His Name?

  • If financial directives, appointments, or theological statements were rushed through before his death, they may have been intended to secure his legacy—or preempt his opponents from reversing them.
  • Were there any sudden resignations or internal reshuffling in the final days of his life?

3. What Was the Vatican’s Real Read on His Condition?

  • If the Vatican knew his death was imminent, why not be transparent?
  • Was the severity of his condition intentionally hidden to prevent destabilization or ensure certain figures remained in control?

The Political Implications of His Death

1. A Power Vacuum Favors the Traditionalists

  • Francis’ opponents now have the opportunity to reverse his agenda.
  • If the conclave tilts toward a conservative successor, his reforms could be rolled back within months.
  • His progressive appointments may not be enough to maintain his vision.

2. Vatican Financial Oversight Could Change Overnight

  • Francis pushed for financial transparency in the Vatican Bank.
  • If his reformist allies lose power, expect a reversal on financial disclosures.

3. The Vatican’s Diplomatic Strategy Will Shift

  • Francis was open to engagement with China and took a cautious stance on Russia.
  • His successor may either continue this or return to a more hardline approach.

Could His Death Have Been Prevented?

1. A Deliberate Slow-Walk?

  • Pneumonia was a known risk, yet the Vatican framed his condition as stable up until his final crisis.
  • Kidney insufficiency was a key factor, but not acknowledged publicly.
  • His continued public engagements suggest an effort to maintain appearances, rather than a focus on his recovery.

2. The Vatican’s Role in His Medical Care

  • Was he receiving the highest standard of treatment or was his care shaped by institutional inertia?
  • If he had been a head of state in another country, would he have survived longer?

Final Analysis: A Death with Consequences

Pope Francis’ official cause of death will remain a matter of record, but the circumstances surrounding it suggest a more complex story.

  • His final days were politically significant, marked by key decisions and appointments.
  • The Vatican’s management of information raises questions about whether his death was simply expected—or institutionally accepted.
  • His passing is not just the end of an era but the beginning of a power struggle.

With Francis gone, the future of the Catholic Church is uncertain.

The conclave to replace him will be the ultimate test of whether his vision for the Church survives—or dies with him.

[@portabletext/react] Unknown block type "image", specify a component for it in the `components.types` prop


3. The Vatican Power Struggle—Who Benefits?

With Pope Francis dead, the Vatican enters one of the most significant power transitions in its modern history. While the public sees a solemn period of mourning, behind the closed doors of the Apostolic Palace and Curia offices, the real battle is already underway. Who controls the future of the Church? Who gains from Francis’ death? And more importantly—who loses?

The immediate power vacuum creates opportunities for factions that opposed Francis’ leadership and reforms. His death is not just the loss of a pope; it is the removal of an obstacle for those seeking to shift the Church back toward a more traditionalist, hierarchical structure.

This section breaks down the major factions within the Vatican, their objectives, and how they stand to gain—or lose—now that Francis is gone.

1. The Battle Lines: Who Wanted Francis Gone?

Francis was a disruptive force within the Vatican. His papacy was defined by financial reforms, doctrinal shifts, and efforts to decentralize power away from Rome. This earned him powerful enemies.

A. The Traditionalists: The Biggest Beneficiaries of His Death

This faction consists of high-ranking conservative cardinals and bishops who opposed Francis’ progressive stances on LGBTQ+ inclusion, interfaith dialogue, Vatican financial transparency, and clergy discipline.

  • Key Figures:
    • Cardinal Raymond Burke (U.S.): A vocal critic of Francis’ approach to Catholic doctrine, sidelined by Francis but still influential among hardliners.
    • Cardinal Gerhard Müller (Germany): Former head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, removed by Francis but still a key theological voice.
    • Cardinal Robert Sarah (Guinea): A favorite among conservatives, known for his defense of traditional liturgy and opposition to Francis’ decentralization.
  • What They Want:
    • A pope who will reverse Francis’ reforms and reassert strict Catholic doctrine.
    • Rollback of Francis’ financial reforms, which imposed stricter oversight on Vatican Bank activities.
    • Stronger Vatican control over bishops worldwide, undoing Francis’ push for regional autonomy.
  • How They Benefit From His Death:
    • They now have the best chance in a decade to elect a conservative pope who aligns with their vision.
    • Without Francis appointing more progressive cardinals, the next conclave is likely to tilt toward their faction.
    • They can quickly move to dismantle his reforms, particularly those regarding Vatican governance and financial oversight.

B. The Vatican Bureaucracy (Curia): The Institutional Power Base

The Roman Curia—the Vatican’s governing body—has long resisted papal efforts to curb its influence. Francis attempted to decentralize power, but many of these officials have outlasted him and remain in place.

  • Key Figures:
    • Cardinal Pietro Parolin (Secretary of State): Now the most powerful man in the Vatican until a new pope is chosen.
    • Cardinal Marc Ouellet (Canada): Former head of the Vatican’s bishop-selection office, a moderate but deeply institutionalist figure.
    • Archbishop Georg Gänswein (Germany): Former aide to Benedict XVI, connected to conservative power brokers.
  • What They Want:
    • A return to Vatican centralization—reducing the influence of regional bishops.
    • Control over Vatican diplomacy and financial management—maintaining the Curia’s hold over global Church operations.
    • A stable, institutionalist pope who will maintain the status quo rather than push radical changes.
  • How They Benefit From His Death:
    • The Vatican’s internal bureaucracy thrives on continuity—the death of a reformist pope gives them an opportunity to slow or reverse his initiatives.
    • Parolin, as Secretary of State, is now in control of the transition process, which means the Curia will shape the next papal election.

C. The Financial Interests: Who Controls the Vatican’s Money Now?

Francis made financial transparency a priority, pushing through anti-corruption measures and oversight of the Vatican Bank (IOR). His death opens the door for those who want to roll back these reforms.

  • Key Concerns:
    • Francis clashed with powerful Vatican financial officials over accountability measures.
    • His death may pause or reverse investigations into Vatican financial scandals involving real estate, offshore accounts, and political bribery.
  • Who Benefits From His Death?
    • Vatican officials and cardinals who resisted financial oversight now have a chance to unwind Francis’ reforms.
    • If a more traditionalist or pro-Curia pope is elected, financial transparency efforts may be weakened.
    • The Vatican Bank’s role in global finance could shift dramatically, depending on the new pope’s stance.

2. Who Loses the Most? The Progressive Wing of the Church

The biggest losers in Francis’ death are his ideological allies, particularly the progressive bishops, theologians, and cardinals who hoped to expand his vision of the Church.

A. The Reformists: A Movement in Jeopardy

  • Francis’ push for decentralization, greater lay involvement, and a more inclusive approach to Church doctrine is now at risk.
  • Without him appointing more progressive cardinals, his wing of the Church has lost a key ally.

Key figures at risk of losing influence:

  • Cardinal Jean-Claude Hollerich (Luxembourg): Led discussions on LGBTQ+ inclusion in the Church.
  • Cardinal Blase Cupich (U.S.): Strongly aligned with Francis’ vision, but now politically vulnerable.
  • Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle (Philippines): Once seen as a potential successor to Francis, but now lacks the numbers in the conclave.

B. The Latin American and Global South Bishops

  • Francis sought to empower bishops from Latin America, Africa, and Asia, shifting the Church’s center of gravity away from Europe.
  • With his death, the European-dominated Vatican bureaucracy could reclaim its dominance.
  • Latin American bishops, in particular, may struggle to maintain their influence.

3. The Next Papal Election: A Turning Point for the Church

With Francis’ progressive appointments outnumbered by conservative cardinals, the next conclave is poised to be one of the most consequential in modern history.

  • Scenario 1: A Conservative Counter-Reformation
    • If a traditionalist pope is elected, expect rapid rollbacks of Francis’ initiatives.
    • The Church could reassert a stricter doctrinal stance, focusing on issues like clerical celibacy, traditional liturgy, and Church authority.
  • Scenario 2: A Centrist, Institutionalist Pope
    • The Vatican’s bureaucratic wing (Curia) may push for a compromise figure who maintains stability but does not aggressively pursue reforms.
    • This would likely be a figure like Cardinal Parolin, who represents continuity over ideological shift.
  • Scenario 3: The Reformists Regroup (Least Likely)
    • If progressive cardinals can rally behind a strong candidate, they could preserve elements of Francis’ vision.
    • However, they are at a numerical disadvantage in the College of Cardinals.

Conclusion: The Vatican Has Already Moved On

Francis’ death is not just the end of his papacy—it is the moment his ideological enemies have been waiting for. The Vatican’s bureaucratic machinery is already shifting, the conclave is being shaped behind closed doors, and the power struggle is fully in motion.

In the coming weeks:

  • The factions will consolidate their influence.
  • Financial and administrative power centers will adjust.
  • The conclave will determine whether Francis’ legacy survives—or is erased.

The fight over the next pope is not just about theology—it is about power, control, and the future of a 1.3 billion-member institution. Francis’ death is not just an ending—it is the start of a new Vatican war.

[@portabletext/react] Unknown block type "image", specify a component for it in the `components.types` prop

4. The Next Pope—Who Takes Power & What It Means

With Pope Francis dead, the Vatican enters its most consequential political event: the selection of his successor. The conclave to elect the next pope is not just a religious event—it is a geopolitical battle that will define the future of Catholicism, the balance of power within the Vatican, and the Church’s role in global affairs.

The question is simple: Does the College of Cardinals choose continuity with Francis’ reforms, or do they install a conservative successor to dismantle his legacy?

Behind the white smoke and sacred rituals, this is a contest of raw political maneuvering, ideological warfare, and global power projection. The winner will shape doctrine, control Vatican finances, and dictate the Church’s political stance on everything from China to LGBTQ+ rights to clerical discipline.

1. How the Conclave Works: The Basics of Vatican Power Transfer

The papal conclave is the most secretive and controlled election in the world. It follows strict rules, but it is far from a purely spiritual process.

  • Who Votes?
    • Only cardinals under the age of 80 are eligible to vote.
    • This means there are currently 124 voting cardinals.
  • Where Does It Happen?
    • The electors will be sequestered in the Sistine Chapel, locked away from the outside world.
    • They will cast ballots twice per day until one candidate receives a two-thirds majority.
  • How Long Will It Take?
    • Historically, conclaves last between two and four days.
    • However, if factions are deeply divided, it could extend beyond a week.
  • What’s the Role of the Camerlengo?
    • Cardinal Kevin Farrell, as Camerlengo, temporarily oversees Vatican operations but does not play a role in the election itself.
    • His main role is to ensure an orderly transition and maintain Vatican financial stability until a new pope is elected.

2. The Main Contenders: Who Is in the Running?

The College of Cardinals is deeply divided. Francis appointed over 60% of the current electors, giving his faction numerical weight, but traditionalists are far more organized and disciplined.

The election will come down to three key factions:

A. The Reformists: The Successors to Francis

This group seeks to continue Francis’ vision—expanding lay involvement, focusing on social justice issues, and maintaining a diplomatic approach to global conflicts.

  • Cardinal Jean-Claude Hollerich (Luxembourg, Age 66)
    • Jesuit like Francis; supports LGBTQ+ inclusion, regional church autonomy, and decentralization.
    • Could carry forward Francis’ synodal reforms but is viewed as too progressive by conservatives.
  • Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle (Philippines, Age 67)
    • Once considered Francis’ preferred successor.
    • Popular in the Global South, with strong support from Latin America, Africa, and Asia.
    • However, not seen as a strong power player—may be too soft to push back against Vatican traditionalists.
  • Cardinal Matteo Zuppi (Italy, Age 68)
    • Archbishop of Bologna; Francis-backed figure with a strong focus on peace and reconciliation.
    • Has diplomatic experience working on Ukraine peace efforts, making him an attractive compromise figure.
    • His biggest problem? Not seen as a decisive leader.

Strengths of This Faction:

  • Majority of voting cardinals were appointed by Francis.
  • Appeals to younger, progressive Catholics.
  • Continues Francis’ focus on decentralization, synodality, and inclusivity.

Weaknesses:

  • No clear dominant figure to rally around.
  • Traditionalists are far more disciplined in vote coordination.
  • Francis’ death may have weakened their influence over Vatican bureaucracy.

B. The Traditionalists: The Anti-Francis Hardliners

This group believes Francis went too far in his reforms and wants to restore Catholic doctrine to a more rigid, centralized model.

  • Cardinal Robert Sarah (Guinea, Age 79)
    • Ultra-traditionalist, outspoken against LGBTQ+ rights, liturgical changes, and Francis’ economic policies.
    • Would roll back nearly all Francis-era reforms, especially on decentralization.
    • Biggest obstacle? Many cardinals fear he is too extreme and would spark a major schism.
  • Cardinal Péter Erdő (Hungary, Age 72)
    • A European conservative with a strong backing from Catholic traditionalists.
    • Less divisive than Sarah but would still push the Church toward a more centralized, doctrinally strict future.
    • Has strong ties to the Vatican’s financial elite.
  • Cardinal Malcolm Ranjith (Sri Lanka, Age 76)
    • Archconservative, anti-reform, hardline Catholic nationalist.
    • Would seek to undo Francis’ modernization efforts and reinforce Vatican control over local churches.
    • A dangerous pick in terms of public relations—his views could alienate younger Catholics.

Strengths of This Faction:

  • Highly disciplined voting bloc—traditionalists coordinate well.
  • Strong support from conservative clergy and major financial donors.
  • Appeals to Catholic institutions that want stability over reform.

Weaknesses:

  • Many Catholics (especially in the Global South) reject extreme conservatism.
  • Might alienate younger generations, pushing more people away from the Church.
  • Could create internal resistance from bishops who benefited from Francis’ decentralization.

C. The Institutionalists: The “Safe Hands” Candidates

This faction is composed of centrist, Vatican-loyal figures who seek continuity and stability rather than radical reform or reversal.

  • Cardinal Pietro Parolin (Italy, Age 70) – The Vatican Insider
    • Currently the most powerful figure in the Church, running the Vatican as Secretary of State.
    • Would be seen as a compromise figure—not too reformist, not too traditionalist.
    • Biggest advantage? He controls much of the transition process, giving him inside leverage.
  • Cardinal Christoph Schönborn (Austria, Age 79) – The Theologian
    • Highly respected intellectual figure.
    • More pastoral than political—might struggle to impose authority over the Vatican machine.
  • Cardinal Marc Ouellet (Canada, Age 80) – The Old Guard
    • Veteran Church leader, but his age makes him an unlikely choice.

Strengths of This Faction:

  • Most appealing to cardinals who fear ideological warfare.
  • Keeps Vatican bureaucracy stable.
  • Less likely to cause schisms within the Church.

Weaknesses:

  • Lacks a strong global vision—more about internal Vatican control.
  • Might be too weak to push back against traditionalists if they consolidate power.

3. What’s at Stake: The Future of the Church

Whoever wins this conclave will define the direction of Catholicism for decades.

  • A Francis-style successor will continue decentralization, social justice priorities, and outreach to marginalized groups.
  • A conservative pope will reassert hierarchical control, restore traditional doctrine, and focus on enforcing strict Catholic orthodoxy.
  • A centrist pope (like Parolin) will prioritize institutional stability but may lack a strong moral vision.

The conclave will be one of the most closely watched events in modern Church history.

[@portabletext/react] Unknown block type "image", specify a component for it in the `components.types` prop

For Francis’ allies, this is the last chance to secure his legacy.

For his enemies, this is the moment to erase it.

5. Geopolitical Implications—How This Shifts Global Catholicism

The death of Pope Francis is not just a religious event—it is a geopolitical shift with profound global consequences. As the leader of 1.3 billion Catholics and the head of a sovereign state, Francis wielded significant influence in international diplomacy, economic policy, and cultural discourse. His successor will inherit not just a Church, but a complex web of geopolitical relationships, financial interests, and ideological conflicts.

Francis’ death has already triggered a scramble for influence among world powers, religious factions, and Vatican bureaucrats. The outcome of the coming papal election will determine:

  • The Vatican’s stance on international conflicts, particularly in Ukraine, China, and the Middle East.
  • The balance of power between Global South Catholicism and the European Church hierarchy.
  • The future of Vatican financial policy and economic influence.
  • The Church’s position on human rights, authoritarianism, and social justice issues.

This section breaks down the geopolitical ramifications of Francis’ death and what to expect in the months ahead.

1. The Vatican’s Role in Global Politics

Though often seen as a religious institution, the Vatican is one of the world’s most unique and enduring geopolitical players.

  • It has diplomatic relations with 183 countries and operates as a sovereign entity.
  • It wields soft power through moral authority and global Catholic networks.
  • The Pope serves as both a religious figure and a political mediator in international conflicts.

Francis expanded the Vatican’s diplomatic reach, engaging with China, Russia, and the Islamic world in ways previous popes had not. His successor will either continue this approach or shift toward a more conservative, Western-aligned stance.

2. The Vatican’s Relations with China: A Fragile Detente at Risk

One of Francis’ most controversial diplomatic moves was his 2018 agreement with Beijing on the appointment of bishops. The deal allowed China to nominate bishops for Vatican approval, a major concession to the Communist Party.

  • Francis saw this as a pragmatic step to ensure the survival of the Church in China.
  • Conservatives viewed it as a betrayal that legitimized Chinese government control over religion.

What happens now?

  • If a conservative pope is elected:
    • The Vatican may take a harder line against China, risking the expulsion of Catholic clergy from the country.
    • The 2024 renewal of the Vatican-China agreement could be scrapped, leading to a new crisis for underground Chinese Catholics.
    • Beijing may retaliate by further restricting Church activities or expelling Vatican diplomats.
  • If a Francis-style successor is chosen:
    • The agreement will likely remain in place, preserving the Vatican’s diplomatic foothold in China.
    • However, China may still test the Vatican’s resolve by cracking down on unregistered Catholic churches.

China prefers a Vatican that remains politically neutral, which is why Beijing has not officially reacted to Francis’ death. However, the next pope’s stance on religious freedom and Taiwan will determine how the relationship evolves.

3. The Vatican and Russia: The Ukraine Dilemma

Francis took a cautious approach to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, avoiding outright condemnation of Vladimir Putin while calling for peace.

  • He angered Ukrainian Catholics by suggesting that NATO provoked the war.
  • His refusal to directly criticize Putin created tension with Western leaders and the Ukrainian government.
  • The Vatican was one of the few major global powers maintaining direct dialogue with Moscow.

What happens now?

  • If a conservative, pro-Western pope is elected:
    • The Vatican could align more openly with Ukraine and NATO, increasing tension with Russia.
    • The Russian Orthodox Church (which supports Putin) may cut ties with the Vatican.
  • If a Vatican-centric, neutral pope is elected (Parolin or a bureaucratic candidate):
    • The Vatican will continue playing a mediator role, keeping communication channels open with Russia.
    • The Church may focus on humanitarian efforts rather than direct diplomacy.

Russia is watching who emerges as pope very carefully, as the Vatican’s stance on the war could influence European Catholic opinion on supporting Ukraine.

4. The Future of Catholicism in the Global South

One of Francis’ most lasting impacts was shifting the focus of the Church toward Latin America, Africa, and Asia.

  • 70% of Catholics now live in the Global South.
  • Francis appointed more non-European cardinals than any pope in history.
  • He emphasized social justice, economic inequality, and local Church leadership.

Will this shift continue, or will the next pope restore European dominance?

  • If a Global South pope (Tagle, Ranjith) is elected:
    • Latin America and Africa will gain greater influence over Church policy.
    • The Vatican will continue focusing on poverty, economic justice, and indigenous rights.
    • The European-dominated Curia may resist efforts to decentralize Vatican authority.
  • If a European or conservative pope is elected:
    • The Church may return to a Rome-centric, doctrinally rigid structure.
    • Global South bishops will lose influence, and Latin America may see further declines in Catholic adherence.
    • Financial and political power will shift back to the Vatican’s old European elites.

The growth of Evangelical Christianity in Latin America is also a major concern—if the Catholic Church fails to engage the region, Protestant movements will continue eroding Catholic influence.

5. Vatican Finances: The Fate of Francis’ Economic Reforms

Francis made significant efforts to clean up the Vatican’s financial corruption. He:

  • Strengthened anti-money laundering measures in the Vatican Bank.
  • Pushed for greater financial transparency after major corruption scandals.
  • Reduced the financial power of some of the Church’s wealthiest factions.

Now that he is gone, the Vatican’s financial policies are up for grabs.

  • If a conservative or pro-Curia pope is elected:
    • Expect rollbacks on financial transparency.
    • The Vatican’s more secretive financial dealings may return.
    • High-ranking officials involved in past corruption cases may regain power.
  • If a reformist successor continues Francis’ policies:
    • The Vatican Bank’s oversight will continue strengthening.
    • Traditionalists within the Curia may push back, fearing exposure of past dealings.

The financial interests behind the Vatican power struggle cannot be overstated. The Vatican manages billions in assets, real estate, and banking operations—who controls these funds directly impacts Church policy.

6. The Vatican’s Influence on Western Culture Wars

Under Francis, the Church took a more moderate, diplomatic approach to Western cultural battles.

  • He was critical of extreme nationalism and opposed the rise of far-right Catholic movements in Europe and the U.S.
  • He took a soft approach to LGBTQ+ issues, signaling greater inclusion.
  • He embraced interfaith dialogue, especially with Islam.

What happens now?

  • A conservative pope could fuel hard-right Catholic movements in Europe and the U.S., bringing the Vatican closer to figures like Viktor Orbán in Hungary and conservative U.S. bishops.
  • A centrist or moderate pope could continue a Francis-style approach, maintaining distance from radical factions.
  • A progressive pope (unlikely) could push the Church further toward social justice movements.

The outcome will directly influence Catholic political activism, from abortion laws to migration policies.

Conclusion: A Moment of Global Realignment

Francis’ death is not just a Catholic event—it is a reshuffling of global religious and political alliances.

  • The Vatican’s stance on Russia, China, and the West is up for negotiation.
  • The future of Catholicism in the Global South depends on who is elected next.
  • The Church’s role in Western political battles will either escalate or de-escalate.

The next pope will not only inherit Francis’ theological legacy but his geopolitical dilemmas.

Whoever emerges as the next pontiff will dictate the Vatican’s role in world affairs for the next decade.

[@portabletext/react] Unknown block type "image", specify a component for it in the `components.types` prop

6. The Catholic Church at a Crossroads—Internal Struggles and Future Direction

With Pope Francis dead, the Catholic Church faces one of the most pivotal moments in its modern history. The ideological battle over his legacy is already underway, with key factions maneuvering to either preserve or dismantle his reforms.

This is not just about theology—it’s about power, governance, and control. The Church now stands at a crossroads:

  • Does it continue in Francis’ progressive direction?
  • Does it return to conservative, centralized authority?
  • Or does it attempt to find a middle path that satisfies neither extreme?

At stake is the future of Catholicism itself, from its internal hierarchy to its global influence.

1. The Church’s Deep Divisions: A Fractured Institution

Francis’ papacy exposed long-standing ideological fractures within the Church. These divisions are now more pronounced than ever:

  • Progressives vs. Traditionalists:
    • Progressives want the Church to modernize, expand lay participation, and take a more pastoral approach to social issues.
    • Traditionalists seek a return to doctrinal purity, centralized authority, and stricter enforcement of Church teaching.
  • Global South vs. European Vatican Leadership:
    • The Catholic Church is growing rapidly in Africa, Latin America, and Asia, while declining in Europe and North America.
    • However, the Vatican hierarchy remains dominated by European clergy.
    • Will the next pope empower the Global South or maintain European dominance?
  • Clerical Authority vs. Lay Empowerment:
    • Francis pushed for greater lay involvement in Church decision-making.
    • Traditionalists believe power should remain with the clergy.

These conflicts are more than theological—they are about control. The conclave will decide which vision for the Church prevails.

2. The Future of Francis’ Reforms: Will They Survive?

Pope Francis introduced major reforms in Church governance, doctrine, and financial transparency. Now that he is gone, every one of these initiatives is at risk.

A. Synodality & Decentralization: A Shift in Power

  • Francis sought to decentralize decision-making, giving bishops more authority over their own regions.
  • This was deeply controversial—traditionalists saw it as a threat to Vatican authority.
  • The next pope will either:
    • Continue empowering bishops, keeping decision-making decentralized.
    • Reassert Vatican control, ensuring all major decisions go through Rome.

If a traditionalist wins the conclave, expect an immediate rollback of these changes.

B. LGBTQ+ and Social Issues: A Tipping Point

  • Francis softened the Church’s rhetoric on LGBTQ+ issues, though he never officially changed doctrine.
  • Many progressive Catholics saw this as a step toward inclusion, while conservatives saw it as a dangerous departure from tradition.
  • The next pope will either:
    • Continue Francis’ pastoral approach, offering more inclusion.
    • Halt any further movement, reasserting traditional teachings.

C. Clergy Sexual Abuse Reforms: Will the Vatican Stay Tough?

  • Francis created stronger procedures for investigating bishops accused of abuse or cover-ups.
  • Many conservatives resented these measures, seeing them as an attack on clerical authority.
  • The next pope will either:
    • Strengthen these policies, increasing accountability.
    • Quietly weaken them, protecting Vatican insiders.

This will be one of the biggest tests of Francis’ legacy.

D. Financial Transparency: A Target for Reversal

  • Francis introduced stricter financial oversight, aiming to eliminate corruption in the Vatican Bank.
  • If a traditionalist or Vatican bureaucrat is elected, expect:
    • A rollback of transparency measures.
    • A return to secretive Vatican financial dealings.

The Vatican’s internal financial structure remains opaque, and Francis’ reforms were deeply unpopular among powerful figures in the Curia.

If his successor is aligned with the old guard, expect Vatican finances to return to their traditional secrecy.

3. The Global Catholic Crisis: Decline in the West, Growth in the South

The Catholic Church is shrinking in its traditional Western strongholds.

  • In Europe and North America:
    • Mass attendance is at record lows.
    • Young people are leaving the Church in droves.
    • Scandals and outdated teachings have driven people away.
  • In the Global South (Africa, Latin America, Asia):
    • Catholicism is growing rapidly, especially in Africa.
    • But Evangelical Christianity is also expanding, pulling people away from Catholicism.
    • The Church must decide whether to focus on the growing Global South or try to reclaim the West.

This is a critical strategic question. Does the next pope:

  • Try to revive Catholicism in the West?
  • Double down on growth in the Global South?
  • Attempt to do both, potentially failing at both?

If the next pope is European, he may focus on shoring up the Western Church. If he is from Africa or Asia, expect a shift toward these regions.

4. The Church’s Financial Future: Declining Donations, Rising Costs

With declining church attendance in the West, financial support for the Vatican is shrinking.

  • The Church relies heavily on donations from wealthy Western countries.
  • But many major donors have stopped giving due to:
    • Sex abuse scandals.
    • Doctrinal conflicts.
    • The Church’s political stances.

At the same time, running the global Church is more expensive than ever.

  • The Vatican’s budget deficit is growing.
  • Dioceses in Europe and the U.S. are closing churches due to low attendance.
  • Catholic schools and hospitals face financial pressures.

If a financially pragmatic pope is elected, expect a push for new revenue streams, possibly including more real estate investments.

5. The Role of Women in the Church: A Future Battleground

One of Francis’ most controversial moves was expanding women’s roles in Vatican leadership.

  • He appointed Sister Raffaella Petrini as Governor of Vatican City, a groundbreaking move.
  • He allowed women to serve as lectors and acolytes, but stopped short of female ordination.

The debate over women’s roles in the Church is intensifying.

  • Progressives want further inclusion, pushing for female deacons and greater leadership roles.
  • Traditionalists want to reverse Francis’ changes, ensuring that only men hold key Church positions.

The next pope will have to decide whether to:

  • Expand female leadership further—risking a conservative backlash.
  • Halt any further progress—alienating reform-minded Catholics.
  • Find a middle ground that satisfies no one.

This issue will become more important as Western Catholics demand greater gender equality.

6. The Final Question: Can the Church Hold Itself Together?

The Catholic Church is not just facing a leadership transition—it is facing an existential crisis.

  • In the West, it is shrinking.
  • In the Global South, it is growing but facing competition.
  • Internally, it is divided between progressives and traditionalists.
  • Financially, it is struggling to sustain itself.

Francis held these tensions together, but now that he is gone, will they unravel?

The wrong choice in the conclave could trigger a crisis:

  • A far-right pope could alienate millions of progressive Catholics, leading to mass departures.
  • A weak centrist pope could fail to resolve internal divisions, leaving the Church paralyzed.
  • A continuation of Francis’ policies could cause further resistance from traditionalists.

This is not just about who becomes pope. It is about whether Catholicism can survive this moment of upheaval.

Francis kept the Church together, but without him, will it stay intact?

The next few months will determine whether Catholicism emerges stronger—or fractures beyond repair.

7. The Battle for the Soul of the Church—Schism or Unity?

With Pope Francis dead and the Vatican preparing to elect his successor, the Catholic Church is at a breaking point. For years, the battle between progressives and traditionalists has simmered beneath the surface. Now, with Francis gone, those tensions may erupt into open conflict.

The Catholic Church has survived centuries of crises, theological battles, and political intrigue. But this moment feels different. The risk of an internal fracture has never been higher.

The fundamental question now is: Does the Church remain united, or does it split into competing factions?

[@portabletext/react] Unknown block type "image", specify a component for it in the `components.types` prop

1. The Growing Threat of Schism: Is a Catholic Split Inevitable?

The Catholic Church has not seen a major schism in centuries, but the internal divisions today are as deep as those that led to past breaks.

  • The Protestant Reformation (1517) fractured Christianity into rival camps.
  • The Great Schism (1054) split Catholicism and Orthodoxy.
  • Now, in 2025, could the Church face another rupture?

Why Schism Feels More Likely Than Ever

  • Traditionalists believe Francis weakened the Church with his reforms, and they want a pope who will restore authority, doctrine, and discipline.
  • Progressives see the Church as outdated and want a pope who will expand inclusion, decentralize power, and modernize doctrine.
  • Francis kept these factions together—but without him, will they remain in the same Church?

In Germany, some bishops have already begun pushing the boundaries of Catholic doctrine. The Synodal Path, a movement for major reforms, has called for:

  • Blessings for same-sex unions.
  • Female deacons.
  • Laypeople having more power in Church governance.

The Vatican has tried to block these efforts, but German bishops have ignored orders from Rome.

If the next pope is too conservative, will progressive bishops split off?
If the next pope is too progressive, will traditionalist bishops reject his authority?

The next 12 months will be critical in determining whether the Catholic Church holds together or fractures into rival camps.

2. The Hardliners: Would Traditionalists Break Away?

If the next pope continues Francis’ progressive vision, some conservative bishops may rebel.

  • Cardinal Raymond Burke and other ultra-traditionalists have openly criticized Francis.
  • Some traditionalist movements, like the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX), already operate outside of Vatican control.
  • In the U.S. and Europe, there is a growing movement of radical traditionalist Catholics who reject Vatican authority.

Could a traditionalist-led schism happen?

  • Scenario 1: Informal Rebellion → Some bishops and priests may simply ignore the Vatican and continue following pre-Vatican II teachings.
  • Scenario 2: A Breakaway Movement → A group of bishops could form an alternative Catholic structure, refusing to recognize the next pope.
  • Scenario 3: A Fully Declared Schism → If the Vatican cracks down too hard, conservative bishops may officially break from Rome.

The last major Catholic schism was the Western Schism (1378-1417), when multiple popes claimed authority.

Could history repeat itself? If the next pope takes an aggressive progressive stance, this could become a reality.

3. The Progressives: Would Reformists Abandon the Church?

On the other side, progressive Catholics are already frustrated.

  • Many felt Francis didn’t go far enough on LGBTQ+ inclusion, women’s roles, and Church governance.
  • Some believe the Church will never fully modernize and are losing faith in Vatican leadership.
  • If a hardliner pope is elected, progressive Catholics could leave in massive numbers.

How Would a Progressive Breakaway Happen?

  • Scenario 1: A Slow Exodus → If the Church becomes too conservative, progressives might quietly leave, stopping donations, attendance, and engagement.
  • Scenario 2: An Open Challenge → Some liberal bishops (especially in Germany) could refuse to recognize a traditionalist pope.
  • Scenario 3: A New Catholic Movement → A global group of progressive bishops could form a new “Reformed Catholic” Church.

The biggest risk for the Vatican is silent abandonment.

  • Traditionalists might break away dramatically, but progressives might simply fade out, leaving empty churches.
  • If millions of Catholics quietly walk away, the Church will face financial ruin and collapse in key Western strongholds.

This is a different kind of schism—one not of rebellion, but of quiet disengagement.

4. Could the Vatican Contain the Crisis?

The Vatican has survived divisions before—but this time, the fractures run deeper than doctrine.

If the next pope wants to hold the Church together, he will need to balance several forces:

  • Reassure traditionalists that doctrine won’t collapse.
  • Reassure progressives that reforms won’t be erased.
  • Prevent bishops from openly defying Rome.
  • Stop mass departures from the Church.

The challenge is that both sides see each other as enemies.

  • Traditionalists believe progressives are heretics.
  • Progressives believe traditionalists are holding the Church hostage.
  • The Vatican is caught in the middle.

If the next pope fails to balance these factions, he may become the first modern pope to preside over a formal split.

5. The Role of Politics: How External Forces Could Worsen the Crisis

The Catholic Church does not exist in a vacuum. The fight over its future is also being influenced by political and cultural forces around the world.

  • In the U.S., the Church is deeply divided along political lines.
    • Conservative Catholics align with right-wing populist movements.
    • Progressive Catholics align with social justice activism.
    • The next pope will determine which side the Vatican leans toward.
  • In Europe, secularism is rising.
    • If the Vatican becomes too conservative, it risks alienating European Catholics completely.
    • If it becomes too progressive, it may accelerate conservative backlash.
  • In Africa and Latin America, Catholicism is competing with Evangelical Christianity.
    • Evangelicals are growing rapidly, especially in Brazil and Nigeria.
    • If the Vatican doesn’t adapt, it could lose millions of potential followers to Protestant movements.

The next pope’s policies won’t just affect the Church—they will shape global politics.

  • A conservative pope could align with nationalist movements in the U.S., Hungary, and Poland.
  • A progressive pope could align with globalist institutions, the UN, and environmental movements.
  • A centrist pope may try to balance both sides, pleasing no one.

The fight for the Church is not just internal—it is part of a global cultural war.

6. The “Nuclear Option”: Could the Church Change Its Structure?

If the risk of schism becomes too great, some Vatican insiders have proposed a radical solution:

A restructuring of the Catholic Church into a more decentralized model.

  • Instead of one pope controlling everything, regional bishops could have greater autonomy.
  • The Church could allow different regions to adapt certain teachings.
  • This would mirror the Orthodox Church model, where different patriarchs govern different regions.

This would be an extreme shift, but it might be the only way to prevent a full break.

If the next pope fears total collapse, decentralization could be his last resort.

7. The Vatican’s Next Moves: A Test of Survival

The Catholic Church has faced crises before—but this one may be its biggest test in centuries.

  • Can it keep traditionalists and progressives in the same institution?
  • Can it prevent bishops from breaking away?
  • Can it stop mass departures in the West?
  • Can it remain relevant in a world that is changing rapidly?

Pope Francis held these forces together. Now that he is gone, the future of the Church is uncertain.

The next 12-24 months will determine whether Catholicism remains a unified global force—or fractures beyond repair.

The battle for the soul of the Church is just beginning.

8. The End of an Era—And the Uncertain Future of Catholicism

The death of Pope Francis is not just the passing of a man—it is the end of a chapter in the history of Catholicism. His tenure was marked by progress, controversy, and internal resistance, and his death has left the Church at a crossroads.

Now, with the Vatican in transition and the conclave looming, the future of Catholicism is uncertain. Will it remain unified? Will it embrace reform or retreat into conservatism? Will it survive the coming internal war?

What happens next will shape the Church for generations.

[@portabletext/react] Unknown block type "image", specify a component for it in the `components.types` prop

1. Pope Francis’ Legacy—What He Changed and What He Failed to Change

Francis entered the papacy as a reformer, but his legacy is complex and deeply contested.

His Major Accomplishments

  • Reforms on Church Governance:
    • Expanded synodality, allowing bishops more autonomy.
    • Appointed more Global South cardinals, shifting influence away from Europe.
  • Financial Oversight:
    • Cracked down on corruption in the Vatican Bank and enforced stricter oversight.
  • A New Approach to Social Issues:
    • Softened rhetoric on LGBTQ+ Catholics, divorced Catholics, and interfaith dialogue.
    • Opened the door for greater lay participation in Church affairs.
  • Diplomatic Engagement:
    • Reached historic agreements with China and Islamic leaders.
    • Attempted to mediate in global conflicts, particularly Ukraine and the Middle East.

What He Failed to Change

  • The Clergy Sexual Abuse Crisis
    • While he introduced stricter procedures, he failed to hold high-ranking officials accountable.
    • Many bishops accused of cover-ups remain in power.
  • LGBTQ+ Inclusion and Women’s Role in the Church
    • His approach was pastoral but not doctrinal.
    • He did not allow female deacons or official blessings for same-sex couples.
  • Conservative Resistance
    • Despite his power, he could not fully overcome the Vatican bureaucracy.
    • Traditionalists blocked many of his reforms and are now poised for a comeback.

His legacy is one of unfinished change. The question now is whether his successor will complete his work—or dismantle it.

2. The Conclave’s Historic Importance—A Defining Moment for the Church

The upcoming papal election is not just another conclave—it is a battle for the future of Catholicism.

The outcome will decide:

  • Whether the Church continues on Francis’ reformist path or returns to doctrinal rigidity.
  • Whether the Vatican remains a global diplomatic force or withdraws into itself.
  • Whether the Catholic Church stays united or fractures into rival factions.

The Three Possible Outcomes

  • A Reformist Pope (Low Probability)
    • Continues Francis’ agenda and pushes for bolder reforms.
    • Risks a conservative rebellion or schism.
  • A Traditionalist Pope (Most Likely Outcome)
    • Restores doctrinal rigidity and centralized Vatican authority.
    • Risks alienating progressives and accelerating Catholic decline in the West.
  • A Centrist Pope (Compromise Candidate)
    • Tries to balance both factions and hold the Church together.
    • May lack the authority to enforce major decisions.

The Vatican prefers stability over chaos, so a centrist or conservative pope is the most likely outcome.

However, if the wrong choice is made, the Catholic Church could enter its greatest crisis since the Reformation.

3. The Real Stakes—What the Next Pope Must Navigate

The next pope will inherit a deeply divided Church in a rapidly changing world.

He must deal with:

  • Declining influence in Europe and North America
    • How can the Church remain relevant when church attendance is plummeting?
  • The rise of the Global South
    • Will the Vatican empower Latin American, African, and Asian bishops—or keep power centralized in Rome?
  • The Vatican’s Geopolitical Role
    • Will the next pope engage with China, Russia, and Western governments—or retreat from politics?
  • The Risk of Internal Rebellion
    • Will traditionalist or progressive factions split off if they don’t like the new pope?

The next pope cannot afford indecision.

  • If he moves too slowly, the Church may continue its decline.
  • If he moves too aggressively, he may trigger a backlash or schism.
  • If he fails to inspire confidence, the Vatican’s global influence may collapse.

No matter who is elected, the next pope will face one of the most difficult leadership tests in modern history.

4. Can Catholicism Survive the 21st Century?

For centuries, the Catholic Church has been one of the most powerful institutions in the world. It has survived:

  • The Roman Empire’s fall
  • The Protestant Reformation
  • The rise of secularism
  • The clergy sexual abuse scandals

But the modern world is unlike any previous challenge.

  • Younger generations are leaving religion entirely.
  • Western governments are no longer politically tied to the Church.
  • Scandals have permanently damaged its credibility.
  • Islam and Evangelical Christianity are outpacing Catholic growth worldwide.

Does the Catholic Church adapt—or become a relic of the past?

  • If it modernizes, it risks alienating its conservative base.
  • If it doubles down on tradition, it risks becoming irrelevant in the modern world.
  • If it tries to balance both, it may satisfy no one.

The next 10–20 years will determine whether Catholicism remains a global force—or fades into historical obscurity.

5. The Vatican’s Strategy Moving Forward—What to Watch For

The Vatican is not just reacting to Francis’ death—it is actively shaping its future.

In the coming months, watch for these key indicators:

  • Who Controls Vatican Messaging?
    • If conservative figures dominate Vatican statements, expect a shift to the right.
    • If Francis-aligned bishops maintain influence, reform may continue.
  • How Quickly Does the Conclave Happen?
    • A rushed election could mean a pre-selected candidate has already been chosen.
    • A longer conclave suggests deep internal divisions.
  • Does the Vatican Clamp Down on Reformist Bishops?
    • If progressive bishops in Germany and Latin America face Vatican discipline, a crackdown is coming.
    • If they are left alone, reformist elements may still have power.
  • What is the Vatican’s First Diplomatic Move?
    • If the new pope immediately engages with China, Russia, or the U.S., he will set the tone for Vatican diplomacy.
    • If he remains silent on global issues, expect a more inward-focused Church.

These signals will reveal whether the Vatican is preparing for continuity—or a dramatic course correction.

6. Conclusion: The Beginning of a New Era—For Better or Worse

Pope Francis’ death is not just a transition—it is an inflection point for the Catholic Church.

The battle for his legacy has already begun.

  • His allies will try to secure his reforms.
  • His enemies will try to erase them.
  • The conclave will determine the fate of 1.3 billion Catholics.

But one thing is certain: The Church will never be the same again.

The next pope will decide whether Catholicism thrives, declines, or fractures completely.

Francis’ papacy was the last great effort to modernize the Church. Now that he is gone, the Church must decide what it stands for—and whether it has a future.

The battle for Catholicism has begun..

[@portabletext/react] Unknown block type "image", specify a component for it in the `components.types` prop

9: The Next 100 Days—What to Expect and How the Vatican Will Consolidate Power

The first 100 days after Pope Francis’ death will define the direction of the Catholic Church for years to come. The Vatican will attempt to project stability, unity, and control, but beneath the surface, power struggles, ideological battles, and strategic maneuvering will shape the next papacy.

This is a period of transition—but also of calculated decisions and internal warfare. The Church is entering an era of uncertainty, and the next few months will determine whether Catholicism remains a global force or fractures beyond repair.

1. The Immediate Aftermath—The Vatican Moves to Control the Narrative

The Vatican has one primary objective in the first few days after Francis’ death: prevent chaos.

  • The funeral and mourning period will be tightly managed to signal continuity.
  • Key Vatican figures will emerge in the media, shaping public perception of Francis’ legacy and preparing the Church for its next leader.
  • The College of Cardinals will quietly begin negotiations, setting the stage for the conclave.

The messaging will be carefully crafted to avoid speculation about divisions, conspiracies, or power struggles. But behind the scenes, the real battle will be taking place.

2. The Papal Funeral—A Display of Power and Control

Francis’ funeral will be the first major event of the post-Francis era.

  • It will be a massive global spectacle, attended by world leaders, religious figures, and Catholic faithful.
  • The seating arrangements and guest lists will be politically significant.
    • Who sits close to Vatican leadership?
    • Which figures are sidelined or omitted?
    • What statements are made during the eulogy?

This funeral is not just about mourning—it is about signaling who is in power.

The Vatican will use symbolism, public statements, and protocol to send a clear message about the future direction of the Church.

3. The College of Cardinals Gathers—Political Deals Begin

With Francis’ body barely in the ground, the College of Cardinals will begin maneuvering for control.

  • Informal alliances will form immediately.
  • The most influential cardinals will emerge as kingmakers.
  • Key factions will start counting votes.

This process is not as spiritual as it appears. Behind the scenes:

  • Diplomatic backchannels will be used to secure commitments.
  • Pressure will be applied to undecided cardinals.
  • Vatican financial interests will play a role in supporting or opposing candidates.

This is the moment when the next pope’s fate will be decided—not in the conclave itself, but in the days leading up to it.

4. The Financial Realignment—Who Controls the Vatican Bank?

One of the biggest hidden battles in the Vatican is over money.

  • The Vatican Bank (IOR) controls billions of dollars in assets, real estate, and secretive financial dealings.
  • Francis implemented financial transparency measures—but now those reforms could be reversed.
  • If a conservative or Vatican bureaucrat is elected, expect an immediate rollback of financial oversight.

Key signs to watch:

  • Are financial transactions frozen or quietly restructured?
  • Are there sudden resignations or removals of Vatican financial officials?
  • Do Vatican-backed businesses shift money before the next pope takes office?

Whoever controls the Vatican’s money controls the Vatican itself.

5. The Conclave—A Vote That Will Define the Future of Catholicism

Within 15-20 days of Francis’ death, the conclave will be held in the Sistine Chapel.

  • 124 cardinals will enter, but only one will emerge as pope.
  • They will be cut off from the outside world, allowed only to communicate through tightly controlled Vatican channels.
  • Voting will take place twice per day until one candidate receives two-thirds support.

The conclave will likely unfold in three key phases:

  1. The First Ballots (Testing the Waters)
    • No clear winner will emerge in the first rounds.
    • Cardinals will use these votes to gauge support for different factions.
  2. The Power Struggles (Eliminating Weak Candidates)
    • Reformist candidates will likely face early elimination unless they can consolidate votes.
    • Conservative and institutionalist candidates will battle for dominance.
  3. The Final Showdown (Compromise or Victory?)
    • If one faction secures control early, their candidate will win decisively.
    • If there is no consensus, a compromise candidate will be chosen to prevent division.

The length of the conclave will indicate how divided the Church truly is.

  • A quick conclave (2-3 days) means a pre-selected candidate had broad support.
  • A long conclave (1+ week) signals deep internal divisions and possible factional conflict.

6. The First Actions of the New Pope—Immediate Policy Shifts

Once the new pope is elected, his first 100 days will be the most critical of his tenure.

The first public statements, appointments, and decrees will determine whether he:

  • Continues Francis’ vision or immediately reverses it.
  • Expands financial transparency or restores Vatican secrecy.
  • Engages with global diplomacy or retreats into a more insular role.

Key signals to watch:

  • Who does he appoint to top Vatican positions?
  • What does his first public speech focus on?
  • Does he reach out to progressives or signal a return to tradition?

These moves will set the tone for his entire papacy.

7. How the World Will React—Political and Religious Implications

The election of the new pope will send shockwaves through religious and political communities worldwide.

In the United States:

  • If the new pope is conservative, expect stronger ties to right-wing Catholic movements and resistance to progressive policies.
  • If he is progressive, expect immediate backlash from U.S. conservative bishops and Catholic political figures.

In Europe:

  • A centrist or traditionalist pope may try to slow the Church’s decline in Europe.
  • A progressive pope could face opposition from nationalist leaders like Orbán in Hungary or Meloni in Italy.

In Latin America and Africa:11

  • The next pope’s approach to poverty, economic justice, and evangelization will determine whether Catholicism continues to grow in these regions.
  • If the new pope ignores the Global South, expect tensions between Rome and local bishops.

The Vatican is not just a religious institution—it is a global power center. The new pope’s stance on diplomacy, finance, and social issues will shape the Church’s influence for decades.

8. Conclusion: A Church on the Brink of Transformation

The next 100 days will be among the most consequential in modern Catholic history.

  • The Vatican will attempt to project stability while internal factions maneuver for control.
  • The College of Cardinals will decide whether the Church moves forward or backward.
  • The financial and political power struggles will determine who truly controls the Vatican.
  • The new pope’s early decisions will shape the Catholic Church’s trajectory for a generation.

Pope Francis’ death has set into motion a defining battle for the soul of Catholicism.

  • Will the Church embrace modernity or retreat into conservatism?
  • Will Catholicism remain united or fracture into rival factions?
  • Will the next pope lead the Church into the future or anchor it in the past?

The next 100 days will answer these questions.

But one thing is certain: The Catholic Church will never be the same again.

[@portabletext/react] Unknown block type "image", specify a component for it in the `components.types` prop

10. The Long-Term Future—Where Does the Catholic Church Go From Here?

The death of Pope Francis and the election of his successor will set the course for the Catholic Church in the short term, but the real question is: What happens over the next decade?

The Vatican is at a critical inflection point. The Church is facing secularization in the West, explosive growth in the Global South, and mounting internal divisions. Its long-term survival depends on whether it can adapt to the 21st century—or if it remains trapped in the past.

This section examines the next 10–20 years of Catholicism, looking at the key challenges and possible futures for the Church.

1. The Catholic Church in 2035—A Growing or Shrinking Faith?

A. The Church’s Continued Decline in the West

For centuries, Europe and North America were the centers of Catholicism. That era is ending.

  • In the United States, weekly Mass attendance has dropped below 20%.
  • In France, Spain, and Ireland—once Catholic strongholds—secularism is dominant.
  • Scandals and doctrinal rigidity have driven millions away from the Church.

If this trend continues over the next decade:

  • More churches and Catholic schools in the West will close.
  • The Vatican will lose one of its main sources of financial donations.
  • Younger generations will grow up with no connection to the Church.

The question is: Will the next pope take steps to stop this decline?

If the Vatican clings to old traditions, it will alienate young people and accelerate its collapse in the West.
If the Church embraces modernization, it may retain members but risk losing its conservative base.

Either way, Catholicism in Europe and North America will never be the same.

B. The Rise of the Global South—Will It Replace Europe as Catholicism’s Power Center?

While Catholicism is shrinking in the West, it is growing rapidly in Africa, Latin America, and parts of Asia.

  • Africa is the fastest-growing region for the Church. By 2050, nearly half of the world’s Catholics could be African.
  • Latin America remains heavily Catholic, but it is losing ground to Evangelical Christianity.
  • Asia, particularly the Philippines and India, has large Catholic populations that are expanding.

Over the next decade:

  • Will the Vatican empower bishops from the Global South?
  • Will an African or Asian pope emerge, breaking the European monopoly on leadership?
  • Will the Catholic Church focus on social justice and economic inequality, responding to the concerns of the Global South?

If the Vatican fails to embrace this shift, it risks losing its most promising future members.

If it fully embraces the Global South, the Church’s center of gravity will shift away from Rome.

2. Will Catholicism Remain Politically Relevant?

For centuries, the Catholic Church was a dominant force in global politics.

  • It helped shape European empires.
  • It played a major role in U.S. and Latin American politics.
  • It acted as a mediator in global conflicts.

But in the 21st century, the Vatican’s political influence is waning.

  • The Church no longer dictates policy in most Western countries.
  • Secular governments are less likely to take Vatican positions seriously.
  • The rise of nationalism has led some governments to reject religious influence.

If the next pope wants the Vatican to remain a global power, he will need to:

  • Engage with China, Russia, and Western nations on equal terms.
  • Play a diplomatic role in conflicts like Ukraine, Israel-Palestine, and climate change.
  • Use Catholic social teachings to influence international development and human rights.

But if the Vatican remains inward-focused, it could fade into irrelevance as a political institution.

The next 20 years will determine whether the Church is still a global player—or just a religious relic.

3. The Church’s Internal War—Will It Hold Together?

One of the greatest dangers for the Catholic Church is not external pressure, but internal collapse.

As covered in previous sections, the risk of schism is higher than at any point since the Reformation.

By 2035, we may see:

  • A fully fractured Catholic Church, with separate progressive and traditionalist factions.
  • A weak Vatican struggling to maintain control over rebellious bishops.
  • Breakaway Catholic movements forming their own independent churches.

The Catholic Church has survived wars, revolutions, and reforms—but it has never faced an internal war at this scale.

If the next two popes fail to hold the Church together, it may split apart permanently.

4. The Vatican’s Financial Survival—Will the Church Go Bankrupt?

The Catholic Church is one of the wealthiest institutions in the world, but its financial future is not guaranteed.

  • Western donations are declining as people leave the Church.
  • Legal settlements from sexual abuse scandals have cost the Church billions of dollars.
  • Some dioceses in the U.S. and Europe are already bankrupt.

By 2035, the Church may need to:

  • Sell off real estate and historical assets to stay afloat.
  • Rely more heavily on wealth from the Global South as Western donations dry up.
  • Engage in more commercial ventures to generate income.

If financial mismanagement continues, the Vatican may face an economic crisis within the next decade.

5. The Future of Catholic Doctrine—Will the Church Modernize or Stay the Same?

One of the most debated issues is whether the Catholic Church will change its teachings to reflect modern values.

Key questions for the next 10–20 years:

  • Will women ever be allowed to become deacons or priests?
  • Will the Church formally recognize same-sex unions?
  • Will birth control and family planning policies change?

If the Vatican refuses to change, it risks losing more members in the West.
If it modernizes too quickly, it risks alienating conservative Catholics worldwide.

The next two or three popes will decide the future of Catholic doctrine.

6. Conclusion: The Future of Catholicism Is Unwritten

Pope Francis’ death is not just a moment of transition—it is a moment of reckoning.

The Catholic Church is no longer guaranteed dominance. It must fight for survival in a rapidly changing world.

The next decade will determine whether:

  • The Church collapses in the West or finds a way to adapt.
  • The Vatican embraces the Global South or clings to European leadership.
  • Catholicism remains politically influential or fades into irrelevance.
  • The Church stays united or fractures into competing factions.

There is no clear path forward—only critical choices that will shape Catholicism for generations.

The new pope’s leadership will be the first test.

But the real question is whether Catholicism itself can evolve fast enough to survive the 21st century.

If it does, it may experience a new golden age.

If it doesn’t, it may go the way of empires, kingdoms, and lost religions—remembered, but no longer relevant.

The Catholic Church has survived for 2,000 years.

The next 20 years will decide whether it survives for another 1,000.

4o